First Date the Musical - First Impressions Lyrics

Broadway's Musical Comedy
First Date the Musical - First Impressions Lyrics

CASEY
(spoken) So, do you agree with Kevin?

AARON
(spoken) About what?

CASEY
(spoken) Am I really cute?

AARON
(spoken) What? You can't just ask me that!

CASEY
(spoken) Why not? You said you were an open book. So, am I?

AARON
She's a little artsy
She's hip and cool
She's just like all those girls
That ignored me all through school
She's kinda indie
And pretty hot
She's a lot like all the things that I am not

There's some Asian symbol
Tattooed on her wrist
She's got the kinda look that says
"Hello, world. I'm pissed."
She's sorta hostile
Her guns are drawn
Is it weird or just screwed up that I'm turned on?

But that's just a first impression
I could be totally wrong
It's only a first impression
And maybe she's

A stuffy and conservative
Way uptight girl who's still a virgin
Never goes past second base
Supressing every single urge
Until she marches down the aisle
And finally ties the knot
She could want a giant family
Be an opera devotee
Hell, even have a PhD
Yes, that's who she could be

CASEY
(spoken) I'm waiting.

AARON
(spoken) Uh, yes, you are very... pleasant looking.

CASEY
(spoken) Pleasant looking?

AARON
(spoken) No, I mean attractive! desirable! stunningly beautiful!
How about D: all of the above?
And what adjectives would you use to describe me?

CASEY
He's a bit annoying
And overdressed
He's got the kinda vibe that says
"Look at me: I'm stressed"

(spoken) Honestly, there are just so many adjectives to choose from, I wouldn't even know where to start.

Probably likes to cuddle
Long walks in the park
And if he likes sex
Then it's only in the dark

But that's just a first impression
I could be totally wrong
It's only a first impression
And maybe he's

A nasty uninhibited
Ferocious tiger in the sack
Who rides a Harley, hits the gym
And makes his money dealing crack
To wealthy kids in private schools
Who treat him like a god
He could kick some ass just like Bruce Lee
Engage in online piracy
And not take any shit from me

Yes that's who he could-

AARON
That's who she could-

BOTH
That's who he/she could be

But that's just a first impression
I could be totally wrong
It's only a first impression
And though the impression is strong
It never can hurt to question
Though I doubt this will lead to romance

AARON
Sometimes the ones who seem great
Are a nightmare to date

CASEY
Either way I've been burned

BOTH
But the one thing I've learned
Is often times first impressions

AARON
Are worth a second glance

CASEY
It's worth a second glance

AARON
A second glance

CASEY
It's worth a second glance

AARON
A second glance

CASEY
It's worth a second glance

BOTH

It's worth a second glance

[Thanks to Miranda for corrections]

First Date the Musical Lyrics

SYNOPSIS
The One
First Impressions
Bailout Song 1
The Girl for You
The Awkward Pause
Allison's Theme 1
That's Why You Love Me
Bailout Song 2
Safer
I'd Order Love
Allison's Theme 2
The Things I Never Said
Bailout Song 3
In Love With You
The Check!
Something That Will Last